I love looking in a bit deeper to these sorts of "Research Papers". I downloaded this after seeing it on one of the RSS feeds I get. I have put a copy I downloaded from the LIUNA site this evening. I always start by looking at the document properties, you can sometimes see who *actually* writes the stuff.PCO “RIGHT TO WORK” PLAN AN ATTACK ON MIDDLE CLASS
LiUNA Local 183 today released “The Reality of ‘Right to Work’: Putting Middle Class Out of Reach”, a paper by economist John O’Grady that refutes absolutely the “Right to Work” plan put forward for Ontario by Tim Hudak’s Progressive Conservatives.
The report done for Local 183 looks at both the Tories’ proposal and the Fraser Institute’s supporting paper from earlier this year and dismantles them piece-by-piece. “So-called ‘Right to Work’ is an attack on unions and the essential role they play in helping working families enjoy middle class life,” said Jack Oliveira, Business Manager for Local 183.
“Right to Work” reduces wages across the board, not just for unionized workers. Workplace injuries rise, pension plans wound up and benefits lost under these American-based initiatives.
The construction industry has been an economic success story for Ontario for over 25 years. It is creating jobs faster than the economy as a whole, has an excellent safety record, provides much-needed skills to thousands of people and provides excellent benefits to its members. “Right to Work” would put all of this at risk.
“Tim Hudak has to explain why he wants to cut our pay and slash our benefits. He needs to explain why construction workers don’t belong in the middle class. What has he got against us?” asked Carlos Morais, a member of Local 183. Morais received two and a half years of free training from the union and is now an Interprovincial Red Seal Brick and Stone Mason.
LIUNA Local 183 is North America’s largest construction union, with over 40,000 members in the Greater Toronto Area, Barrie and Cobourg. Members work in construction including sewer and water main, residential, road construction, bridge building, pipeline, utilities and railroads.
General Counsel, LIUNA Local 183
(416) 241-1183 x6558 John O’Grady
Prism Economics & Analysis
My point here is that John O’Grady (The author) works at “Prism Economics and Analysis” and will probably be a bit pissed at whoever finalized that thing for release. Go ahead, open the linked document, then go to “Properties”.
It says it was written by “Bill Empey” the Managing Director at Prism but I guess Empey wrote something called “Literature Review and Expert Advice to Inform Canada’s Immigration Levels Planning: Final ReporT” (sic) and then someone somehow got them crossed. I guess Prism just flips the old reports over and writes on the back of them.
Then I thought, let’s Google that report name… it's pretty interesting. You find a document leaked in 2012 about the changes coming to the government’s immigration policies. So the Managing Director of a union friendly agency writes a government report that gets leaked to the press and then another union friendly report turns up with the same name. I am tired and don’t want to dig around anymore but it sure is weird. I think Prism should try a little harder.
Hopefully someone else can pick this up and do some sluething. I do know that I am going straight to the LIUNA site tomorrow to see if they still have the same version on their site.